Happy Whatever

By Louis Borgenicht

Despite this my office persona is clearly Jewish and some of my patients have a hard time figuring what to say to me in these politically correct times.
 
There are several predictable patterns.   

Covering all their bases some say, "Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukah. and  Happy Kwanza."
Those unsure of my affiliation say but knowing I am Jewish say, "Happy Hanukah."
Some with a hesitating sense of insecurity born of political correctness say, "Happy (long pause) Holidays."
 
To those who are unsure and seemingly uncomfortable with how I deal with the holidays I usually explain, "We are going to have a quiet Christmas and will  light the Hanukah candles but don¹t celebrate other than that." For those who ask, very few, I mention that we buy Hanukah candles at The Pottery Barn  for ten dollars. My wife thinks the colorful but irregular boxes from Israel  you buy at the synagogue are tacky. I have acquiesced to her aesthetic.
 
Furthermore, the music around the December holidays takes its toll on me. The Nutcracker Suite has been anathema to me for years for several reasons. Radio stations start playing it earlier and earlier in the year as if to get ready for the holiday season months ahead. One year it got so annoying that I offered a pledge to my local NPR station if they would promise not to play it; they took my money and continued to play it.
 
If given my druthers I would have the Faure Requiem playing 24/7 throughout December.
 
Then there are the ever present Christmas carols and songs by the Mormon Tabernacle Choir. I turn the radio off as soon as I hear them. They make me want to shop when I don¹t want to.
 
Christmas has become unwound and is grossly misconstrued in these difficult times. My perspective on giving has to do with true friendship and not obligation. We should give only when the spirit and time moves us: the right thing for the right person whenever.
 
Meanwhile I resist the coercive pressure of all aspects of the holiday  season. My office radio is silent; I await the next patient¹s confusion about my spirituality or lack of it; and I preach my gospel of avoidance of
conspicuous consumption at every opportunity.

A few years ago we rented an apartment on the Seine between Christmas and New Years. No commercial insanity (the French have a different perspective on Noel it seemed), no Nutcracker, and no Rudolph.
 
Bless us all.

ADVERTISEMENT

COMMENTS

  • Wendy Wurlitzer

    Parisian Lover Wendy Wurlitzer 1 Comments
    I appreciate your honesty about the holidays and your feelings towards them. Having spent a year in Munich studying, I would agree with you in that the European's approach to the holidays is beautifully understated. I was there in '75, but would imagine it is still somewhat similar. You are so right in terms of the music played this time of year. It is hideous how it is played constantly and how the songs are so poorly juxtaposed. Yes, I do like Christmas music but prefer hearing one type of music at a time. Thank-you for blessing us all and a Happy New Year to you!
  • Joannasings

    Parisian Lover Joannasings 1 Comments
    Renting an apartment on the Seine? That's NOT conspicuous consumption? Since when is that the cheap rent district? You most certainly are a conspicuous consumer. If you really weren't, wouldn't you want to rent a place in a less expensive or less prestigious location to demonstrate your lack of consumerism and snobbishness? And ten dollar Hanukah candles? If that isn't conspicuous consumerism I don't know what is.
    While I agree with you on many of your points re the commercialization of the holidays, and especially agree with you about some of the more egregious musical sins, your comments vis a vis Hanukah, Reconstructionist Judaism and the Chabad are truly nasty. The tone in your very first paragraph is condescending and snide. Your sarcastic inference about the mission of Hillel at U.of Utah is offensive. It sounds as though you are oblivious to the anti-semitism that is again growing in the world, including in Paris and other places in France. Maybe it doesn't matter to you. I'm glad it matters to Hillel! Although I am a Jewish woman who adores Paris and the rest of France as much as I love the USA, it doesn't leave me blind to the fact that anti-semitism exists and must not be ignored. For any thinking human being, it must not be ignored or made light of.
    As for making your patients squirm with an explanation of your holiday views, why can't you just say "thank you" and let it go at that? No one needs to know how you REALLY feel. It falls into the "more information than I need" category. You could be equally gracious by wishing them a happy holiday, but it doesn't seem to square with your rather selfish worldview. I notice you mention nothing about what you say to them, which does say a lot about you.
  • T.A. Kidd

    Parisian Lover T.A. Kidd 1 Comments
    One persons' view;calm,interesting and universal to all who would see.
  • Charles Kravitz, DDS

    Parisian Lover Charles Kravitz, DDS 1 Comments
    Pointless, boring. A waste of readers' time.

You must login to leave comments...

Premium Membership

Bonjour Paris is the Guide to Paris written by the top insiders in Paris. Join now and uncover all the secrets most American tourists will NEVER discover about Paris.

PARIS WITH KIDS GUIDE

Traveling to Paris with children? Our guide will show you all the best kid friendly places in Paris.